Generous Justice: How God’s Grace Makes Us Just

Timothy Keller, in Generous Justice, offers a passionate plea and biblical defense of social justice. In the current emotionally charged climate of political attack, this book points to the gospel of grace as the only right motivation for taking up the cause of widows, orphans, immigrants, and the poor. The book is fast-paced and warm–brimming with scripture, anecdotes, and practical application.

Keller is the pastor of Redeemer Presbyterian Church in New York City and author of New York Times bestseller The Reason for God. Generous Justice He is an ordained minister in the Presbyterian Church in America and holds degrees from Bucknell University, Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary, and Westminster Theological Seminary. After pastoring a church in Hopewell, Virginia, he taught at Westminster before planting Redeemer Presbyterian Church in 1989.

According to Keller, Generous Justice was written for four types of people. First, he has witnessed an increased number of young Christian believers who have a great desire to serve in justice ministry. Many of these young adults, however, have a hard time connecting that desire to their Christian faith. Second, Keller targets those Christians who are fearful that any advocacy of social justice is inexorably linked to a loss of sound doctrine and evangelism. The third audience includes those who do, in fact, abandon traditional evangelical doctrines like justification by faith alone and Jesus’ substitutionary atonement as they seek social justice. Finally, he argues against the “new atheism,” which contends that religion is regressive and promotes injustice and violence.

The first third of the book is a biblical overview of justice, from Genesis to Revelation. Being created in the image of God displays God’s design for human dignity and the reflection of harmonious, peace-filled relationships. Though the Fall in Genesis 3 shattered relationships, it did not negate human dignity and worth. Throughout scripture, God consistently identifies with the poorest of the poor, the widow, and the orphan. This “identification,” Keller explains, finds its fullest expression in the incarnation, where Jesus was born in a feeding trough and possessed no material wealth of his own. He rode on a borrowed donkey into Jerusalem and was buried in a borrowed tomb. God has identified with the outcast and the ostracized fully in the person of Jesus Christ, and thus calls us to strive for generous justice.

So what does “justice” mean? According to Keller, doing justice includes defending people’s rights, identifying with the poor and oppressed, serving the widow and orphan, caring for the victims of unjust treatment, and bringing shalom to broken relationships and communities. Striving for generous justice is not simply a biblical suggestion, but a biblical command. Indeed, radical generosity is biblical generosity. While salvation is by faith alone, a “key sign” of saving faith is seeking social justice.

The book reveals faults of both political liberals and conservatives in their methods of giving, taxation, and their attempts to “fix” the problems of societal injustice. Just as Keller doesn’t hold back in challenging conservative churches who only help those who are morally upright and hard working, so also he doesn’t hold back in confronting liberal churches for diminishing the importance of proclaiming the gospel message. Real compassion for the poor and oppressed entails risk and sacrifice, truth and selfless giving.

From cover to cover, Generous Justice is sprinkled with practical applications. Keller goes into great detail to explain how doing justice for social change comes from immediate relief, individual and community development, and social reform. He also gives advice on how to work for social justice with unbelievers in a spirit of “humble cooperation” and “respectful provocation.” He challenges both individuals and churches to live out a radical generosity; thoughts of helping the homeless or fighting for human equality should constantly be on the mind of every Christian as a response to the grace he or she has been shown in the gospel. He writes, “Grace is the key to it all” (40). The grace of God in Christ Jesus is the foundation and proper motivation for doing justice. Keller emphasizes the absolute centrality of the gospel for God-glorifying service to the poor and broken.

I have but one criticism of the book: it seems, at times, unorganized and without direction. Even though each chapter has helpful subtitles, I found myself asking, “How does this section relate to the chapter?” At other places, Keller seems to be jumping from one idea to another without a reasonable flow. Notwithstanding, I heartily recommend this book and applaud Keller’s clear exegesis, his balanced approach, and his passion for social justice. Ultimately, Generous Justice looks to the generosity of God and his free gift of saving grace to lay “the foundation for the society of justice for all” (40).

Brian H. Cosby is an ordained minister in the Presbyterian Church in America and serves on pastoral staff at Carriage Lane Presbyterian Church in Peachtree City, Georgia.